This is me personally.
If I see a design I like, I download it. If it also flies well, I upvote it.
If it needs some work I leave a comment and upvote it. If it flies like crap, I leave a comment and don't upvote. But that's rare.
@jsaret to expand on your post, alt account abuse could maybe be reduced by only giving points per unique account that downloads the plane. That way, people would have to register a new account every time to hike their score up
@DelphFoxFan that's not a bad idea, although it would probably have to stop counting after a certain point. The famous Droplet has nearly 70,000 downloads
This seemed interesting, so I go the downloads and votes for my most popular designs and a random bunch of less popular ones as well.
Name DLs Votes Ratio Type
Hawk 11031 66 167 Replica
Triebflugel 4749 59 80 Replica
JAST 2198 43 51 Replica
Taranis 1984 38 52 Replica
ES-335 449 35 13 Replica (non-plane, high part count)
Laura 1914 34 56 Replica (Battlestar Galactica)
Lancer 252 28 9 Replica
Copperbell 708 21 34 Original
Cariburn 890 17 52 Replica (Ace Combat)
Eagleray III 543 20 27 Original (challenge)
Roundels 58 14 4 Toolbox
Fuath 53 7 8 Original (challenge)
Peallaidh 192 3 64 Original (challenge, winner)
MiG-15 157 12 13 Replica
Martlet 65 5 13 Original (challenge, winner)
Exocoetus 9 1 9 Original
Nightwing 78 12 7 Replica (Warhammer 40,000)
Warton 7 2 4 Replica
Nosferatu 22 1 22 Replica (Ace Combat)
Valkyrie 80 7 11 Original
Bobbitworm 24 7 3 Original (challenge, runner up)
Saab 21 6 3 2 Replica
Hawkmoth 5 2 3 Original (challenge)
Freestyle 32 7 5 Replica (challenge)
Then, ordered by the best ratio to the worst:
Name DLs Votes Ratio Type
Saab 21 6 3 2 Replica
Bobbitworm 24 7 3 Original (challenge, runner up)
Hawkmoth 5 2 3 Original (challenge)
Roundels 58 14 4 Toolbox
Warton 7 2 4 Replica
Freestyle 32 7 5 Replica (challenge)
Nightwing 78 12 7 Replica (Warhammer 40,000)
Fuath 53 7 8 Original (challenge)
Lancer 252 28 9 Replica
Exocoetus 9 1 9 Original
Valkyrie 80 7 11 Original
ES-335 449 35 13 Replica (non-plane, high part count)
MiG-15 157 12 13 Replica
Martlet 65 5 13 Original (challenge, winner)
Nosferatu 22 1 22 Replica (Ace Combat)
Eagleray III 543 20 27 Original (challenge)
Copperbell 708 21 34 Original
JAST 2198 43 51 Replica
Taranis 1984 38 52 Replica
Cariburn 890 17 52 Replica (Ace Combat)
Laura 1914 34 56 Replica (Battlestar Galactica)
Peallaidh 192 3 64 Original (challenge, winner)
Triebflugel 4749 59 80 Replica
Hawk 11031 66 167 Replica
I dunno if there's any kind of observable pattern there, other than that it gets steadily worse as you get more popular. My pre-gold ones average at 12.625 downloads per vote, my post-gold ones average 56.333
Yeah, IMO it's pretty bad. Remember, though, many people that like your creation will download it several times because they forgot to save it, etc.
My best thing has like 320ish downloads and 11 upvotes, which is still depressing.
Don't expect 1:1 though. 10:1 is more realistic as an upper limit, unless it's a challenge, or some non-classic-vehicle, those are all over the map.
That makes sense @DelphFoxFan
@Hadesrocks Well then they make it so downloading your own plane doesn't count as a point.
@DelphFoxFan but then you can keep downloading your own planes or others planes
@SUPERSAMROCK I guess that's the way it should be.
I don't get people who like a plane enough to download but not to upvote.
That is nice of you @skubadogg
This is me personally.
If I see a design I like, I download it. If it also flies well, I upvote it.
If it needs some work I leave a comment and upvote it. If it flies like crap, I leave a comment and don't upvote. But that's rare.
Yes! I know @Allstar
Points are easy to get, though... @SkyborneFox
@Allstar or they don't have enough points to be allowed to upvote.
@Skua perfect solution!
@jsaret no, I don't mean requiring an account to download, just that downloads by by people without accounts shouldn't provide points for the builder
@Skua but is requiring an account for downloading a good idea? If it is, then the devs could change the downloads stat to "people who have downloaded"
Wow that's a lot of data, thanks for the time @Skua
@jsaret to expand on your post, alt account abuse could maybe be reduced by only giving points per unique account that downloads the plane. That way, people would have to register a new account every time to hike their score up
I made a post on this a while back...
@Skua Maybe something like maximum 100 points?
@Skua Yep XD
@DelphFoxFan that's not a bad idea, although it would probably have to stop counting after a certain point. The famous Droplet has nearly 70,000 downloads
Tbh I think a download should count as 1 or 2 points.
This seemed interesting, so I go the downloads and votes for my most popular designs and a random bunch of less popular ones as well.
Then, ordered by the best ratio to the worst:
I dunno if there's any kind of observable pattern there, other than that it gets steadily worse as you get more popular. My pre-gold ones average at 12.625 downloads per vote, my post-gold ones average 56.333
But do include the website counts downloads with people who don't have accounts
Yeah, IMO it's pretty bad. Remember, though, many people that like your creation will download it several times because they forgot to save it, etc.
My best thing has like 320ish downloads and 11 upvotes, which is still depressing.
Don't expect 1:1 though. 10:1 is more realistic as an upper limit, unless it's a challenge, or some non-classic-vehicle, those are all over the map.
Ok that is good to know, thanks @Skua
@SUPERSAMROCK whilst it is terrible, it's not something you're doing wrong, it's a problem with the entire community
Lol that's what I thought, it is my time traveler @Allstar