Profile image

Is 432 downloads and two up votes a bad ratio?

21.2k SUPERSAMROCK  8.7 years ago

Is it?

  • Log in to leave a comment
  • Profile image

    That makes sense @DelphFoxFan

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    4,164 Glaceon

    @Hadesrocks Well then they make it so downloading your own plane doesn't count as a point.

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image

    @DelphFoxFan but then you can keep downloading your own planes or others planes

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    712 skubadogg

    @SUPERSAMROCK I guess that's the way it should be.
    I don't get people who like a plane enough to download but not to upvote.

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    21.2k SUPERSAMROCK

    That is nice of you @skubadogg

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    712 skubadogg

    This is me personally.
    If I see a design I like, I download it. If it also flies well, I upvote it.
    If it needs some work I leave a comment and upvote it. If it flies like crap, I leave a comment and don't upvote. But that's rare.

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    7,655 WhiteWing

    Yes! I know @Allstar

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    15.9k Allstar

    Points are easy to get, though... @SkyborneFox

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image

    @Allstar or they don't have enough points to be allowed to upvote.

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    17.8k jsaret

    @Skua perfect solution!

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    26.2k Skua

    @jsaret no, I don't mean requiring an account to download, just that downloads by by people without accounts shouldn't provide points for the builder

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    17.8k jsaret

    @Skua but is requiring an account for downloading a good idea? If it is, then the devs could change the downloads stat to "people who have downloaded"

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    21.2k SUPERSAMROCK

    Wow that's a lot of data, thanks for the time @Skua

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    26.2k Skua

    @jsaret to expand on your post, alt account abuse could maybe be reduced by only giving points per unique account that downloads the plane. That way, people would have to register a new account every time to hike their score up

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    17.8k jsaret

    I made a post on this a while back...

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    4,164 Glaceon

    @Skua Maybe something like maximum 100 points?

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    4,164 Glaceon

    @Skua Yep XD

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    26.2k Skua

    @DelphFoxFan that's not a bad idea, although it would probably have to stop counting after a certain point. The famous Droplet has nearly 70,000 downloads

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    4,164 Glaceon

    Tbh I think a download should count as 1 or 2 points.

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    26.2k Skua

    This seemed interesting, so I go the downloads and votes for my most popular designs and a random bunch of less popular ones as well.

     Name           DLs     Votes Ratio Type
    
     Hawk           11031   66  167 Replica
    
     Triebflugel    4749    59  80  Replica
    
     JAST           2198    43  51  Replica
    
     Taranis        1984    38  52  Replica
    
     ES-335         449     35  13  Replica (non-plane, high part count)
    
     Laura          1914    34  56  Replica (Battlestar Galactica)
    
     Lancer         252     28  9   Replica
    
     Copperbell     708     21  34  Original
    
     Cariburn       890     17  52  Replica (Ace Combat)
    
     Eagleray III   543     20  27  Original (challenge)
    
     Roundels       58      14  4   Toolbox
    
     Fuath          53      7   8   Original (challenge)
    
     Peallaidh      192     3   64  Original (challenge, winner)
    
     MiG-15         157     12  13  Replica
    
     Martlet        65      5   13  Original (challenge, winner)
    
     Exocoetus      9       1   9   Original
    
     Nightwing      78      12  7   Replica (Warhammer 40,000)
    
     Warton         7       2   4   Replica
    
     Nosferatu      22      1   22  Replica (Ace Combat)
    
     Valkyrie       80      7   11  Original
    
     Bobbitworm     24      7   3   Original (challenge, runner up)
    
     Saab 21        6       3   2   Replica
    
     Hawkmoth       5       2   3   Original (challenge)
    
     Freestyle      32      7   5   Replica (challenge)
    

    Then, ordered by the best ratio to the worst:

    Name            DLs Votes Ratio Type
    
    Saab 21         6       3   2   Replica
    
    Bobbitworm      24      7   3   Original (challenge, runner up)
    
    Hawkmoth        5       2   3   Original (challenge)
    
    Roundels        58      14  4   Toolbox
    
    Warton          7       2   4   Replica
    
    Freestyle       32      7   5   Replica (challenge)
    
    Nightwing       78      12  7   Replica (Warhammer 40,000)
    
    Fuath           53      7   8   Original (challenge)
    
    Lancer          252     28  9   Replica
    
    Exocoetus       9       1   9   Original
    
    Valkyrie        80      7   11  Original
    
    ES-335          449     35  13  Replica (non-plane, high part count)
    
    MiG-15          157     12  13  Replica
    
    Martlet         65      5   13  Original (challenge, winner)
    
    Nosferatu       22      1   22  Replica (Ace Combat)
    
    Eagleray III    543     20  27  Original (challenge)
    
    Copperbell      708     21  34  Original
    
    JAST            2198    43  51  Replica
    
    Taranis         1984    38  52  Replica
    
    Cariburn        890     17  52  Replica (Ace Combat)
    
    Laura           1914    34  56  Replica (Battlestar Galactica)
    
    Peallaidh       192     3   64  Original (challenge, winner)
    
    Triebflugel     4749    59  80  Replica
    
    Hawk            11031   66  167 Replica
    

    I dunno if there's any kind of observable pattern there, other than that it gets steadily worse as you get more popular. My pre-gold ones average at 12.625 downloads per vote, my post-gold ones average 56.333

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    49.1k Flightsonic

    But do include the website counts downloads with people who don't have accounts

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    17.8k jsaret

    Yeah, IMO it's pretty bad. Remember, though, many people that like your creation will download it several times because they forgot to save it, etc.
    My best thing has like 320ish downloads and 11 upvotes, which is still depressing.
    Don't expect 1:1 though. 10:1 is more realistic as an upper limit, unless it's a challenge, or some non-classic-vehicle, those are all over the map.

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    21.2k SUPERSAMROCK

    Ok that is good to know, thanks @Skua

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    26.2k Skua

    @SUPERSAMROCK whilst it is terrible, it's not something you're doing wrong, it's a problem with the entire community

    8.7 years ago
  • Profile image
    21.2k SUPERSAMROCK

    Lol that's what I thought, it is my time traveler @Allstar

    8.7 years ago
  • Log in to see more comments