Airplanes
@Bobplanes322
Snoopy's Sopwith
Handling: 5/10
Detail: 9.5/10 VERY creative!
Take-off and Landing:4.5/10 (T:4 L:0.5) Take off: Jumpy, but good. Landing: I could not line it up at any Final Approach (I never landed it, it veered of course and fell into the water). Only at very short distances would it actually land.
Realism: 23/25 Good, but Snoopy is not a replica of WWI (I did not remove any points for this though but in replicas, fictional items should not be present...) Color could use a tiny tune up... Great Job!
Total points: 42
@airsoft
Fokker dr.1
Handling: 7/10 Crazy start, and some times stalls.
Detail: 8/10 Cockpit could should be a little more detailed.
Take-off and Landing: 8.5/10 (T:3.5 L:5) Crazy take-off, but is okay...
Realism: 23/25 Missing some symbols... Very Good job!
Total Points: 46.5
@DownUnderWing
Fokker Dr.1
Handling: 9/10
Detail: 8.5/10 Cockpit and prop. could be a little better...Very nice body!
Take-off and Landing: 9.5/10 (T:4.5 L:5) I landed it first time in the valley at 100 mph! Great.
Realism: 23/25 Very good, but could be a bit better with the cockpit and prop. connection...
Total Points: 50
@TheOwlAce
WWI Challenge Submission
Handling: 9/10 Great handling, but veers left often.
Detail: 8/10 Amazing cockpit and pilot! Could have more symbols.
Take-off and Landing: 8/10 Take off is great... but could be a bit more stable. Landing is Okay (My bad, I had trim setting up... Sorry for previous score)
Realism: 24/25 Could use a little more fuselages for wing support, but body shape is amazing! P.S. the red and blue on the tail need to be switched...
Total Points: 49
@KamikazeMLG
WWI Challenge
Handling: 7 Much better, I am in control of its flight, rather than it being in charge!
Detail: 8/10 Symbols are great, but is lacking a letter and/or number on the front or back... Love the engine!
Take-off and Landing: 10/10! The first time I tried to take off and land I got it perfect! It hits smoothly and gets lift much better than before!
Realism: 24/25 Great job! I looked up a picture, and your plane looked almost identical to the real thing! Great!
Total Points: 49
@Leonelarminrocks7
FOKKER TRIPLANES DV.1
Handling: 9/10 Your plane flew wonderfully! It was one of the best, but was a little jumpy on the Pitch.
Detail: 4.5/10 I really like the plane, but feel that it was a little plain, and should have had more color variation. (Cockpit was great!)
Take-off and Landing: 9/10Take-off (4.5 points) the plane flys wonderfully, but veers right greatly. Landing (4.5) points) the plane can land nicely, but dips down with out the engine and can not compensate.
Realism: 18/25 I liked the plane, but found that the body needed to be a little longer and have more color variation and symbols. I also took away 5 for the jet, but love to fly the plane.
Total points: 40.5
@GhostHTX
SE5A V2
Handling: 7/10 Good, but violent on the pitch and requires a certain angle a elevation to not flip and spin out.
Details: 5/10 Missing some symbols and decals that I would love to see. Color is perfect!
Take-off and landing: 6/10 Take-off is okay (Read more in Handling) Landing is tricky, the planes tends to explode.
Realism: 18/25 The body was right on but missing so me key details (Details) and functionality. I am impressed with the wings!
Total points: 36
Dh.2
Handling: 6/10 Must push down every second to keep it from stalling and jumping off course.
Detail: 7.5/10 Cockpit should be in designated cockpit place you made, and color variation would be nice.
Take-off and Landing: 6.5/10 (T:3.5 L:3) Must push down every second to keep from veering of course.
Realism: 22/25 Most DH.2 had 4 prop. fins, but some had two. <-OK Good wing structure and like I said, cockpit in designated cockpit area... Great job.
Total points: 42
@Kerabango
AGO C.II
Handling: 8.5 Rather well, but a little jumpy, it dips down.
Detail: 10 Amazing!
Takeoff and landing: 7.5 (Takeoff: 4.5 Landing: 2.5 very hard to line up, but hits the ground gently!)
Realism: 25 Perfect!!!!!!!
Total: 50
Cars
@XXLIFESAVERZXX
Handling: 9 Turns and drives well.
Details: 9 Vey nice!
Realism: 15 Nice, colors could be changed... Not quite WWI though........
Total Points: 37
@Sparrow007
Mark IV Male
Handling: 9/10 Great for such a large tank!
Detail: 10/10 Love the guns!
Realism: 25/25 Perfect!
Total: 44
Boats
@pushthelimits
USS San Diego
Handling: 8 Good, a little slow on turns, but floats very well.
Detail: 9 Very Good! Great guns!
Realism: 24 Very good, just a little more that could be added.
Total: 41
@ChasingHorizon
Handling: 7
Detail: 10 Great job!
Realism: 24 Very few thing that I wanted better...Near Perfect!
Total Points: 41
I would totally fail.
@TheOwlAce Welcome
@Joco80 i wasnt focused on color sceme since i was more occupied with the cockpit. And thank you for giving me secobd place
I know... Why @TheOwlAce
Ya...I know, I just judged in comparison to the others... You did get second... @TheOwlAce
And shes french ~v^
They are WW1 aircraft, they werent well know for being "stable" its called torque, and my plane vering alittle to the left just addes realism
@GhostHTX Ya, maybe, I have Simple Planes on IOS and PC and test all on PC, so that may change it. They control differnetly...
@Joco80 No, that wont be required. Im not trying to imply I should have won or that you did a bad job or anything like that; just that I experience different flight characteristics from you with the exact same model. I am on iOS, though; maybe that has something to do with it?
@GhostHTX ??? Not on my computor, Iwill try again if you want though...?
@Joco80 Im a little confused by your appraisal here; the Dh.2 I built doesnt do the things you mention at takeoff or in flight. It takes off deadstick, becoming airbourne at around 100mph.
https://www.simpleplanes.com/Forums/View/566492 Final Results!
Ya, it was great, I have an old kindle with a charging problem... I understand @pushthelimits
I agree with your point, though. I wish I could have added in the rigging and the Windows, but it would lag as I turned it with only the Windows in the builder.
@Joco80 Not bad for my first boat, though. I have a Kindle, so I am kind of limited before the thing just can't/won't work anymore.
Ya I know...sorry I had to dock points. But I wanted a replica... Next time you did great @Leonelarminrocks7
@joco80 yeah..... sry for the jet. I needed it for speEd....... :(
I wil be adding as more entry come in.