1945-1950 Naval Aviation Challenge (Closed)
1945-50 Naval aviation challenge
TLDR
Build an aircraft in use from 1945-1950 for any navy. Can be fictional or replica. You get upvotes depending on how many criteria points you get as well as your overall ranking.
The top three builds are:
1. SimplyPlain’s Martin Mauler with 64 points
2. Tang0five’s B’BURN B.46 “Firebrand” TF Mk.5 with 63 points
3. RamboJutter’s RJ SeaCommander F2 with 62 points
The challenge is now closed and the results are on a forum post
Welcome to the 1945-1950 Naval Aviation Challenge! This is my first challenge so I hope you all enjoy it.
The goal is to make a naval aircraft which can take off and land on a ship or water. This means that amphibious aircraft, flying boats, and helicopters are also allowed. However, the aircraft should look and perform as if they were in naval service during the years 1945 until 1950.
To take part in this challenge, you must have your build be a successor. Your build may not have fire and forget air to air missiles (so only guardians!) but is allowed to have guided torpedos and bombs. Mods are not allowed but XML modifications are allowed and encouraged!
Your uploads can be either real or fictional, but the fictional aircraft should look like it was an aircraft that would have been used during this time. If the aircraft is a replica, it needs to be one that was used by a naval power during the years 1945-1950. It is also possible to modify real aircraft into naval versions which can take off and land on an aircraft carrier. Players are allowed to create three entries. The first of these must be an original creation but the second and third can be re-uploads of previous posts you have made (it has to have been posted by you!)
There are several criteria that will be looked at and these are:
1. Design: 20 points (does it look like a realistic design from the era? Does it look like it would be used by a navy from that time period? If the build is a replica, does it look like the original aircraft?)
2. Functionality: 10 points (does your plane function the way a naval plane of the time would such as having folding wings, the ability to connect to a catapult, takeoff and land on an aircraft carrier with ease)
3. Performance: 15 points (is your plane easy to control, Is it too manoeuvrable? Not manoeuvrable enough? Is it too fast or slow? Does it perform the way an aircraft from the time period would perform?)
4. Build quality: 15 points (is the aircraft detailed? Does it use simple stock or custom wings, landing gear, cockpit etc.? How smooth is the overall design?)
5. Paint scheme: 5 points (does it look good? Did aircraft in use at the time have similar paint jobs? Did you add numbers, art, or insignias?)
6. Personal opinion: 5 points (did I enjoy how it flew or looked?)
This means you can achieve a total of 70 points.
1st place: 20 upvotes
2nd place: 15 upvotes
3rd place: 10 upvotes
This challenge is also going to work a little different than others I have seen on here. For every ten points your aircraft gets, you will receive one upvote. This counts for the first, second, and third place too.
This means that the highest possible score is 27 upvotes!
I will upvote all of your entries as a thank you for participating. I will also post your scores in a comment on your upload and in a separate forum post after I have finished looking at all the entries.
The deadline for this challenge will be 23:59 (ECT) 7 December 2020.
If you have any questions, please feel free to ask in the comments or in an unlisted version of your post.
Good luck everyone and have fun!
link to plane in this post: https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/4y6hnm/Comet-US-NAVY
Specifications
Spotlights
- DeathStalker627 4.9 years ago
- RhysBrown 4.9 years ago
- hopotumon 4.9 years ago
- asteroidbook345 4.9 years ago
- Tang0five 4.9 years ago
General Characteristics
- Successors 80 airplane(s) +8482 bonus
- Created On iOS
- Wingspan 114.8ft (35.0m)
- Length 46.1ft (14.0m)
- Height 82.0ft (25.0m)
- Empty Weight 16,624lbs (7,540kg)
- Loaded Weight 39,667lbs (17,992kg)
Performance
- Power/Weight Ratio 0.339
- Wing Loading 124.5lbs/ft2 (608.0kg/m2)
- Wing Area 318.5ft2 (29.6m2)
- Drag Points 857450
Parts
- Number of Parts 374
- Control Surfaces 5
- Performance Cost 946
The challenge is now closed. I want to thank everyone who participated as this challenge was a lot of fun to watch grow. I have already almost finished marking all the planes and they were incredibly fun to fly and test out. I will post the scores individually on your own entries and then on a forum post too
His “Martin” mauler is potentially dangerous
It’s a naval strike fighter. Could be fitted with bombs or rockets, but was seen most with a torpedo.
@TheTwoanie2000
I dont agree with the second place. The Blackburn firebrand was a torpedo bomber not a fighter. THERE IS NO TORPEDO
@JOEMAMA07 no problem buddy and good luck!
Thx for the help @Mustang51 :D
@AircraftoftheRedStar thank you!
Awesome! Good luck on the final ones!
@Mustang51
@SovietBun not yet
@Mustang51 is this closed?
@FlyingHueman it’s CET so Amsterdam time
@Mustang51 Most excellent! Mind if I ask you what your timezone is again? I don't expect to take that long, but who knows, lel
@FlyingHueman you have until it ends so you still have a little time left
@Mustang51 Just to clear a doubt up, we've got until January 7 starts or until it ends? I ask because I'm making a third build and now that I fixed some of its problems I need to touch it up and write a description, lol. Not that it'd be a problem if I can't get it finished in time, two submissions is already a lot and frankly more than I was expecting to do.
@ND40X okay cheers!
@Mustang51
You will see...
Also, I will tag you on these things :3
@ND40X those sound like very cool builds! Let me know when they are up. Also for the challenge too. What type is it going to be?
@Mustang51
I'm also going to make another challenge, so look out for that
@Mustang51
Then I want to make a General Aviation, personal transport (single seat) aircraft that has a single jet engine
@Mustang51
I currently have a 3-engined (my first one) bomber with a rotary bomb bay and rocket boosters. It will be called: 'The Silver Phantom'
@ND40X well thanks for that buddy! Do you have any aircraft in the works?
@Mustang51
Same here XD
@ND40X in terms of what I was expecting? I’d give it 10/10 because it did exponentially better than I thought it would hahaha
@Mustang51
Ends tomorrow, huh?
out of 10, what would you rate the successfulness of this challenge?
here's mine! https://www.simpleplanes.com/a/403IxJ/Mitsubishi-A6M2-N-Rufe-France