Profile image

Credits, unlisted and plagiarism.

Mod BaconAircraft  2.3 years ago

Happy Sunday for everything reading this. I hope to quickly address this well-overdue topic and trend I've been seeing on this site.


Successors.

Let's not forget about the predecessor and successor system. It exists so one can modify, improve and add on to preexisting designs. As many can tell, using this system properly will result in the Auto-Credit bar appearing on the top.

This is acceptable, and encouraged as long as sufficient improvement, modification or, variety has been appended to the original. However, making an unlisted successor chain by yourself and burying the original deep down that chain is plagiarism, and will not be tolerated, and treated as a copy.

I have seen this to avoid Auto-Credit increasingly often of the past few weeks, and I encourage everyone who's doing it to put themselves into the shoes of the original creator, how would you like it if your hard work was taken with credit given nonchalantly in the fine print buried deep down many links... If you have accidently done this, no problem - you may re-upload by changing the predecessor link in the plane's XML file, or just tag a mod.


Unlisteds.

Let me be clear. If something is unlisted, it means the creator willingly shared it to you to trust you to have an exclusive look at it before it goes public or it is finished. It is not a bargain bin of free stuff. The same rules still apply.

If you have obtained an unlisted from another user, and wish to append, modify and upload a variant based on it, I would strongly encourage you to ask the original creator before doing so.

Many people's projects takes months to complete, and uploads unlisted as a backup for themselves, or a milestone to share with their friends. Again, if you were shared an unlisted, you were given trust to have a look at their works early - don't breach their trust by uploading their work before them. This is blatant plagiarism and is absolutely not tolerated.


Side note: The Unlisted Exchange.

While this is not site related, I still feel it is important to address. The Unlisted Exchange is a discord server I created long ago that acts as a repository where users can share their unlisteds. Many cases recently have consisted of people taking these unfinished builds without permission of the author and uploading it themselves. If this server is continuously abused in this way, and we cant respect something as simple as people's opinions and their works - then we can't have nice things and I will shut it down. No more exceptions.


Plagiarism.

I think this game provides a platform for users to carry over the importance of incremental improvements, shared projects and concept of successors and rights/credits in the real world on a small scale.

Personally, I feel like many users' grasp on plagiarism exists only as a strict warning from teachers in secondary or higher education. But I would like to remind everyone that plagiarism is no joke. In higher education and in the working world - especially aviation and engineering, plagiarism is taken in an extremely serious manner. Violation or breach of trust in this regard or submitting others' works is almost immediately a termination of duties and punishment via academic probation, or legal and financial.

Of course it goes without saying that none of these consequences apply on the site, but I would like it if people can consider what effects plagiarism have in the real world so we can better respect author's works and use the Auto-Credit system with more responsibility in mind.


Thanks for taking some time out of your day to read this. I know this does not apply to most users, but a friendly reminder never hurts. :)

  • Log in to leave a comment
  • Profile image

    Side note I’d like to add to this post if you do submit a copy report, please include a link to what it is a copy to if there is no auto credit link provided, it’s a lot easier for us to look into it than if it just is stated as “stolen” or “copied” with no link to what it was taken from, would be greatly appreciated!

    Pinned 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    1,420 THEOKPILOT

    @MrSilverWolf good.

    3 months ago
  • Profile image

    @THEOKPILOT if you had made sufficient amount of changes and uploaded it, with credit given that is perfectly fine

    3 months ago
  • Profile image
    1,420 THEOKPILOT

    @MrSilverWolf I made a modified version of someones TBD Devastator. I asked if i could upload(to be courteous), however, they didnt respond. What should i do?

    3 months ago
  • Profile image
    28.6k YarisSedan

    @Bellcat wiimini deleted his account and left Rip... And just hoping that wiimini and ren have at least go outside and touched a grass...

    1.8 years ago
  • Profile image
    7,344 Bellcat

    @DatRoadTrainGuy19, they are already back and you can still visit their profiles.

    2.2 years ago
  • Profile image

    Entire accounts are still built on stealing and it's so annoying lmfao. I'm glad some are gone but one stole builds(or just parts of them) for like 3 weeks unnoticed. I think what usually has to happen is they have to steal a build that either people recognize or the build of a higher point and fairly active user

    +1 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    Thank you so much for keeping our heads up mod group. This will be noted.

    +1 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    Their strikes are more than enough to remind them, there is no need to mention or tag them. I’m sure they don’t appreciate the attention. The issue is in the past, let’s not open the can of worms that have just been sealed, ok? @DatRoadTrainGuy19

    +2 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    Don’t start new drama please. It doesn’t help anyone. @DatRoadTrainGuy19

    +1 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    Thanks for keeping our heads up mod team. This will be noted.

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    31.1k ALTMTR

    And no one would notice it, it's troubling to say the least.

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    31.1k ALTMTR

    One such nick I noticed is that you could outright remove the successor by doing some exploit in the designer. I wouldn't mention it but I'm sure a many seasoned players have actually knew how to do it. It could worsen the case of people who made the design and others taking the design, use the exploit, and benefit off it.

    +1 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    31.1k ALTMTR

    @BaconAircraft At the very least, issue is made known and people got around to talk about it. Maybe in such time, there would be a bit of awareness towards these acts and it could warrant more attention towards the actual accounts doing these thefts.

    Maybe by reporting or flagging them of such acts but I'm sure it would likely be used for nefarious reasons.

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    @ALTMTR That is a fair question, and to be honest I don't know if it will ease the situation either, we will have to see. However, something is better than nothing, and who knows? Maybe it already have deterred some. You miss 100% of the shots you don't take.

    +3 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    @BaconAircraft @MrSilverWolf congrats on making mod you two

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    31.1k ALTMTR

    One such concern is their inclination towards reading this kinds of post, these copycats have an attention span by a millisecond so how is this going to stop many others who are neck deep into stealing people's stuff and claiming their own?

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    @JacksEpicGamingYT unless you delete them

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    @JacksEpicGamingYT ???

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    33.0k SyntheticL

    @BaconAircraft On the way

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    Go right ahead. @SyntheticL

    2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    How about generally modified builds like modifying the body, putting other parts not just painting it and slapping with weapons and airline liveries with text, whether posted public or unlisted? Do they fall under the stolen or copied category?

    +1 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image
    33.0k SyntheticL

    You mind I translate this into Chinese mandarin and post it to chinese forums/QQ groups ?

    +2 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    Sorry dude i thought this was the link for my kfc food

    +1 2.3 years ago
  • Profile image

    @JacksEpicGamingYT ?

    2.3 years ago
  • Log in to see more comments